It’s the summer of ’15, and the song “Things Happen” by Dawes is getting significant airplay on my local radio station. If you haven’t heard it, tune in to the video at 1:31, 2:18, and 3:09:
The song settled in my brain beside the memory of an old Dunkin’ Donuts advertising campaign. Check out the commercial below. The jingle “doing things is what I like to do” is similarly catchy but also meaningless. What are these things? Why does the writer/actor/Dunkin’ Donuts coffee drinker like to do them?
Then I thought of Taylor Swift’s “Shake It Off,” with the redundant
line “players gonna play, play, play, play, play and haters gonna hate, hate, hate, hate, hate.”
While there might be a purpose for these hollow phrases in
pop culture, in academic writing, they just cause frustration and confusion.
After all, in an essay, you do not have the amazing vocal range,
instrumentation, or attitude; you just have words on a page that should
resonate with readers and compel them to continue. If readers start to think Huh? or—worse yet—Duh! after a particular sentence, then you have lost them and your
essay won’t get the attention it deserves.
In the Writing Center, we often talk about the paragraph as
the unit of power in an essay. Today I want to take that discussion even
narrower, to sentences and to individual words. A paragraph is only as
meaningful as its parts. Let’s look at some examples.
Sentences that are too broad
In today’s society, education is an important topic.
This sentence is likely the first one in a student’s paper.
The student wants to guide the reader into the essay’s subject matter
carefully, with some background. I can see that. However, in this case, the
sentence is just too general. What exactly
is “today’s society”? Sure, education is an important topic, but what aspect of education? The keys for revision are to (a) determine a
subtopic and (b) make the reader care.
Possible revision to
narrow the focus: Because of the steady decline in U.S. high school
graduation rates over the past 10 years
(Smart, 2015), New York school administrators have developed greater retention
efforts.
I used a variety of counseling tools on many occasions.
Like the previous example, this sentence does not tell me
much. What are these tools? How were they
used, and when precisely? As a reader, I want to grab hold of an idea and
sink my teeth into it. This kind of sentence leaves me gnawing at air.
Possible revision to
narrow the focus: As a counselor, I used active listening, open-ended
questions, and eye contact in my initial interviews with clients.
Sentences that are unnecessary
Nurses have a plethora of knowledge about nursing.
The student in this example is essentially saying that nurses nurse (similar to Swift’s “haters
gonna hate”). In a revision, more specific aspects of nursing should be
conveyed so that the reader sees the true power of this nursing knowledge.
An employee is defined as “a person who works for another person or for a company for wages or a salary” (“Employee,” 2015, para. 1).
Chances are, an educated reader will already know what an
employee is, so this definition is not needed. Sometimes it can be hard to
determine what kind of knowledge a reader brings to your material. You should
trust that a reader will understand common concepts in everyday adult life.
Imprecise words to watch out for
Thing and stuff. These words can refer to such a wide
range of circumstances and contexts that you should eliminate them.
Many or most. How many is many? Replacing these
adjectives with numbers aids precision.
Nowadays. This
term can mean 2015, the past 20 years, or sometime in between. In revision,
pick a precise year or time frame.
These problematic sentences and words might be easier to
locate in other people’s writing than your own. That is because you approach
others’ text without any specialized knowledge or attachment. Eventually, though,
with practice, you will be able to assess your own writing for these overly
broad or unnecessary sentences.
Practice: I challenge you to write a rough draft of your next assignment and then leave it on your computer for a day or two. Return to the document with fresh eyes and scrutinize the phrasing, looking for some of the indicators I have addressed in this post. How could you infuse those sentences with greater power? Share your thoughts and findings in the comments!
Never miss a new post; Opt-out at any time
No comments:
Post a Comment